Direct identification of bacteria in clinical respiratory samples using fluorescent amplicon length analysis of 16S–23S rRNA spacer-region

Abstract

We describe the development and application of a rapid and universal molecular technique for direct identification of multiple bacteria in clinical samples. Amplification of the 16S–23S rRNA spacer-region using universal primers led to fragment patterns distinct for different bacterial species and that were analyzed with fluorescent amplicon length analysis (FALA). 136 pure cultures of clinical isolates and 20 culture collection strains belonging to 22 different medically important species were used to create a primary database of fragments with sizes between 100 and 1000 bp. Subsequently, 127 respiratory samples were analyzed with culture-based techniques and via FALA of the 16S–23S rRNA spacer-region. Two DNA extraction methods were evaluated: Instagene® (FALA-I) and Fastprep™ (FALA-P). Of the 127 samples, 26 culture-negative samples were also negative with FALA-P. Of 18 samples with growth of commensal oral flora, 10 gave a mixed oral flora pattern with FALA-P and 8 gave a negative result. For 54 samples with growth of a single bacterial species, FALA-P gave an identical result for 46. For 29 samples with growth of more than one bacterial species, identical results were obtained in 19 samples. False-negative results with FALA-P were mostly due to paucity (less than 10 3 CFU/ml) of bacteria (12 out of 18 false-negatives) or difficulties with homogenization of viscous samples (6 out of 18 false-negatives).With regard to identification of all significant pathogens of clinical samples tested, the sensitivity of FALA-P was 77% and its specificity was 100%. With FALA-I, the number of false-negative results was higher than with FALA-P due to less efficient extraction of DNA, particularly with Staphylococcal species. FALA-P allows rapid and direct identification of multiple species directly from clinical samples; pauci-cellular samples may give false-negative results.