Diagnosis of external ventricular drainage related infections with real-time 16S PCR and third-generation 16S sequencing

Abstract

Objective Investigate the performance of real-time 16S PCR and third-generation 16S sequencing in the diagnosis of external ventricular drain related infections (EVDRI). Methods Subjects with suspected EVDRI were prospectively included at Uppsala University Hospital. Subjects were included into three groups: subjects with negative CSF culture with and without antibiotic treatment and subjects with positive CSF culture, respectively. CSF was analysed with real-time 16S PCR and third-generation 16S sequencing. Real-time 16S PCR positivity/negativity and number of 16S sequence reads were compared between groups. For culture positive subjects, species identification in third-generation sequencing and routine culture was compared. Results 84 subjects were included. There were 18, 44 and 22 subjects in the three groups. Real-time PCR was positive in 17 of 22 subjects in the culture positive group and negative in 61 of the 62 subjects in the two culture negative groups. The sensitivity and specificity for real-time 16S PCR compared to culture was estimated to 77% and 98%, respectively. Species identification in 16S sequencing and culture was concordant in 20 of 22 subjects. The number of 16S sequence reads were significantly higher in the culture positive group than in both culture negative groups (p < 0.001). There was no significant difference in number of 16S sequences between the two culture negative groups. Conclusions Real-time 16S PCR predict culture results with sufficient reliability. Third-generation 16S sequencing could enhance sensitivity and species identification in diagnostics of EVD-related infections. False negative culture results appear to be uncommon in patients with suspected EVDRI.