Determining the Stone Free Rate of Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery. Which Radiological Technique? RIRSearch Study Group

Abstract

ObjectiveTo evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of ultrasonography and kidney ureter bladder radiography(KUB) for the determination of stone free status of retrograde intrarenal surgery(RIRS) according to different stone free status definitions. Materials and methodsThe patients who underwent RIRS between September 2021 and September 2022 were prospectively included in the study. All patients underwent a KUB radiography, urinary system ultrasonography and non-contrast abdominal tomography(NCCT) at the postoperative first month of the surgery. The sensitivity, specificity, negative predictive factor, and positive predictive factor of ultrasonography and KUB on evaluating the stone free rate were analyzed according to different stone free status definitions. ResultsA total of 178 patients were included in the study. The stone free rates according to stone free definitions as; residual stone<4mm,<2mm and no residual stone were 79.2%,64.0% and 56.7%,respectively. According to its definition as a residual stone<4mm, the sensitivity and specificity of ultrasonography were 64.9% and 84.3%,respectively. The sensitivity of ultrasonography was 57.1% and 52.5% as the definitions were residual stone<2 mm and no residual stone,respectively. Addition of KUB to USG slightly increased the sensitivity but did not change the specificity. ConclusionUltrasonography had high specificity but low sensitivity for evaluating stone free status after RIRS and addition of KUB did not increase the diagnostic efficacy. Although USG may be used in daily practice, it may overestimate the stone free status and NCCT must be used during the clinical trials to document the exact stone free rates of RIRS.