Determination of economic weights for breeding traits in indigenous Nguni cattle under in-situ conservation

Abstract

This study was conducted to determine the economic weights of most preferred traits in young breeding Nguni bulls and first parity cows. Fifty-four farmers from low-input cattle production enterprises participated in the choice experiment. Sixteen individual animal profiles were formulated from four traits of three levels each using a fractional orthogonal design of SPSS 14.0 (2005). 120 pair-wise choices were deduced for each breeding animal class. A total of 6480 (54×120) observations were obtained for each class of the animals. Data was subjected to multinomial logit (MNL) models using econometric software NLOGIT 4.0.1 Version (2007). All computed economic values for bull traits were significant (p<0.05). The economic weights of bull traits were poor body condition score (−0.99±0.095), good body condition score (0.45±0.073), over-conditioned (base level), low tick infestation (0.57±0.103), medium tick infestation (0.58±0.084), high tick infestation (base level), high aggression and mating behavior (4.41±0.095), average aggression and mating behavior (2.53±0.094), and low aggression and mating behavior (base level). The economic weights of first parity cow traits were poor body condition score (−0.06±0.055), good body condition score (1.08±0.061), over-conditioned (base level), low tick infestation (1.50±0.059), medium tick infestation (0.83±0.067), high tick infestation (base level), age at first calving of ≤27 months (2.37±0.068), age at first calving of 27–36 months (1.30±0.076), and age at first calving of >36 months (base level). Farmers were willing to pay R37,939 (US$4864) for a bull with high aggression and mating behavior score and R17,185 (US$2203) for a first parity cow of less than 27 months old. Enterprise ownership and demographics factors of the farmers were significant in determining economic weights within trait levels. Economic weights were high for reproductive efficiency of the breeding animals followed by the high adaptive characteristics. The choice experiment procedure can be the tool for determining importance of animal characteristics under low-input production systems. It is recommended to make use of the economic weights of preferential traits in designing selection models.