Cytogenetic and Interphase FISH Analyses of 73 Basal Cell and Three Squamous Cell Carcinomas: Different Findings in Direct Preparations and Short-Term Cell Cultures

Abstract

Cytogenetic analysis performed on 73 sporadic basal cell carcinomas (BCCs) and three squamous cell carcinomas (SCCs) showed different findings in direct preparations (24 hours) and in short-term cell cultures. Except for loss of the Y chromosome, not one of the other clonal ( +6, +16, add(2)(q37), del(3)(q13), add(1)(p31), and near triploidy) or sporadic changes found in direct preparations was found in cell cultures and vice versa. Clonal trisomy 6 found in two BCC direct preparations and demonstrated by interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization in 8 other cases seems to be a nonrandom change in basal cell carcinoma. Immunohistochemistry showed that the cell type investigated was different in the two methods of analysis used: epithelial in direct preparations and fibroblastic in cell cultures. Thus, the results obtained in direct preparations indicate the BCC or SCC epithelial karyotype, whereas the aberrations found in cell cultures indicate the presence of chromosome instability in the fibroblastic stroma. The apparent lack of correspondence between direct and indirect preparations and the presence of clonal chromosome changes in both epithelial and stromal cells suggest tumor cell heterogeneity of BCC. The fibroblastic stroma seems to be implicated in the neoplastic process. This is not evident in SCC, in which clonal changes are present only in direct preparations. The chromosomal distribution of the breakpoints involved in structural changes in direct and cell culture preparations is random; together with those reported in the literature, the breakpoints found in BCC cultures show, however, a cluster to 1p36, 3q13, 9q22, 14p11, 15p11, and Xp11 bands. We did not find any significant correlations between BCC cytogenetic results and the clinical data (site, age, sex, recurrence). The incidence of cases of BCC (38%) and of SCC (100%) showing clonal chromosome changes agree with their benign and malignant nature, respectively. Finally, a significantly high incidence of constitutional inv(9) and dup(9)(q11q21) was found in the group of patients with BCC.