CT of the Larynx: Is an Additional High-Resolution Acquisition Necessary for Diagnostic Accuracy?

Abstract

Diagnostic CT of the larynx is historically performed with a protocol that combines a standard neck CT with dedicated imaging through the larynx. Multichannel CT scanners, however, allow high-resolution reformatted images of the larynx to be created directly from the initial neck acquisition data. The purpose of this study was to determine whether reformatted laryngeal images derived from a standard neck CT acquisition provide information comparable with that of separate dedicated high-resolution laryngeal images. The CT protocol for suspected laryngeal masses at our institution consists of a standard neck acquisition followed by a second acquisition focused on the larynx. We enrolled 200 patients who had undergone this protocol for a suspected laryngeal mass. Two head and neck radiologists independently reviewed each of the 200 scans twice. In one session, the entire scan was available, while in the other session, only images derived from the standard neck acquisition were available. The main outcome variable was the frequency of discrepant tumor staging between the interpretation sessions. No pathologic reference standard was used. Radiologist A had discrepant staging in 45 of the 200 scans (23%; 95% CI, 17%-29%). Radiologist B had discrepant staging in 42 of the 200 scans (21%; 95% CI, 16%-27%). Fifty-three of the 87 discrepancies (61%) reflected improper downstaging of the laryngeal tumor on standard images alone, while the other 34 (39%) had improper upstaging on standard images alone. Reformatted images from our institution's standard neck CT acquisition were less accurate than dedicated images of the larynx for analysis of laryngeal tumor extension. Focused images of the larynx were needed to optimize interpretation.