Abstract
Where Are We Now?The current study by Won and colleagues concluded thatpatients undergoing revision ACL surgery have a greaterincidence of significant varus alignment compared withpatients undergoing primary ACL reconstruction. Theauthors also observed that this varus alignment was asso-ciated with meniscal pathology and degenerative changesof the knee. The report of varus alignment provides aninteresting observation that goes a step beyond the findingsof the Multi-center Anterior (C)ruciate Revision Study(MARS) [1], but leads to more questions than answers. Thearticle does not tell us about the results of performing ahigh tibial osteotomy at the time of the revision ACL. Itmerely points out that these patients are potential candi-dates for such a procedure.The strength of the manuscript is that it reminds us thatvarus malalignment is a potential variable to be mindful of.It also serves to warn surgeons they should be aware ofpossible failure of the graft, and continuing pain related tomedial compartment degeneration. Won and colleagues’attention to detail in establishing an effective protocol forthe long-leg films is important because standing long-legradiographs are fickle in terms of being able to demonstrateconsistently the true amount of coronal plane alignment.Where Do We Need to Go?Kimandcolleagues[3]reportedthatasidefromextremecaseswith varus thrust (without medial compartment arthritis) thestability and functional scores were not adversely affected byprimary varus alignment. Kim and colleagues [3]alsoreported that aside from extreme cases where varus thrust isnoted, (in addition to the post meniscectomy changes) theradiographic features of unicompartmental osteoarthritis areinsufficient to be associated with graft failure.Another MARS study [2] indicated that a significantnumber of revision surgeries were related to technicaldifficulties in graft tunnel placement in the primary pro-cedure. This raises a number of questions. Was thedegenerative process and progressive varus at fault incausing the ligament failure in the other revision surgeriesnot related to graft tunnel placement? Which patients needproximal tibial osteotomies at the time of revision ACLsurgery? Should a high tibial osteotomy be performed toavoid postsurgical medial joint line pain? Will concomitantrealignment increase the chance of establishing stability orwould staging the two procedures not only eliminate the
Highlights
The current study by Won and colleagues concluded that patients undergoing revision ACL surgery have a greater incidence of significant varus alignment compared with patients undergoing primary ACL reconstruction
Kim and colleagues [3] reported that aside from extreme cases where varus thrust is noted, the radiographic features of unicompartmental osteoarthritis are insufficient to be associated with graft failure
Another Multi-center Anterior (C)ruciate Revision Study (MARS) study [2] indicated that a significant number of revision surgeries were related to technical difficulties in graft tunnel placement in the primary procedure
Summary
The current study by Won and colleagues concluded that patients undergoing revision ACL surgery have a greater incidence of significant varus alignment compared with patients undergoing primary ACL reconstruction. The authors observed that this varus alignment was associated with meniscal pathology and degenerative changes of the knee. The report of varus alignment provides an interesting observation that goes a step beyond the findings of the Multi-center Anterior (C)ruciate Revision Study (MARS) [1], but leads to more questions than answers. It merely points out that these patients are potential candidates for such a procedure. The strength of the manuscript is that it reminds us that varus malalignment is a potential variable to be mindful of. Won and colleagues’ attention to detail in establishing an effective protocol for the long-leg films is important because standing long-leg radiographs are fickle in terms of being able to demonstrate consistently the true amount of coronal plane alignment
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a callDisclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.
