Abstract
Background and AimsThis study explores the role of the public health advocacy coalition in alcohol policy development in Ireland. Compared with industry actors, much less is known about the membership, activities and influence of public health advocates in alcohol policymaking. To address this gap, this paper identifies several advocacy strategies, drawn from the advocacy coalition framework and other policy theories, and then analyses them in the context of recent Irish developments.MethodsThe study used theory‐building process‐tracing to construct a record of the public health advocacy coalition and its campaign to promote the Public Health (Alcohol) Act 2018 in Ireland. Specifically, we drew upon 131 primary documents produced by advocates, 464 newspaper articles and 18 semi‐structured interviews with key advocates, public health experts and elected officials to undertake a thematic analysis.ResultsPublic health advocates in Ireland have developed sophisticated political strategies to foster major alcohol policy change. First, public health advocates led the formation of a broad‐based advocacy coalition that helped members to effectively pool their limited resources as well as coordinate their strategy and messaging. Secondly, issue‐framing and message discipline played a key role in the coalition's success. Advocates strategically focused upon the policy problem, specifically health harms, rather than the detailed content of the proposed measures. Finally, there is evidence of political learning, where advocates’ prior experiences and knowledge of the political system in Ireland spurred innovations in campaigning. These strategies were interdependent and mutually reinforcing, and succeeded in building support for public health advocates’ preferred policies among politicians and the general public.Discussion/conclusionThere are distinct capabilities that public health actors can mobilize in the policy process to win alcohol policy debates and capitalize on the constraints on industry influence on alcohol policymaking.
Highlights
For more than two decades alcohol policy issues have been prominent in Ireland, with the growing recognition that alcohol-related harms merited legislative responses [1]
A 2012 report prepared by the Steering Group on a National Substance Misuse Strategy (NSMS) linked rising consumption to increasing rates of alcohol-related deaths, suicides and chronic illnesses [6]
Drawing upon concepts from policy studies [25] we identify different policy change mechanisms, including coalition-building [26], issue-framing [27] and political learning [28,9]
Summary
For more than two decades alcohol policy issues have been prominent in Ireland, with the growing recognition that alcohol-related harms merited legislative responses [1]. A 2012 report prepared by the Steering Group on a National Substance Misuse Strategy (NSMS) linked rising consumption to increasing rates of alcohol-related deaths, suicides and chronic illnesses [6]. Despite recognition of this problem, a legislative response was slow to develop. Much less is known about the membership, activities and influence of public health advocates in alcohol policymaking To address this gap, this paper identifies several advocacy strategies, drawn from the advocacy coalition framework and other policy theories, and analyses them in the context of recent Irish developments
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary 
Published Version (
Free)
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a call