Contractual Limitations of Liability and their Impact on Tort Claims

Abstract

Abstract By concluding a contract, parties intend to allocate the contractual risk between them. This means that parties must anticipate any future adverse result and determine whether a party will have to cover any loss incurred by the other party as a result of performance or, more often, bad performance. In sales contracts, for example, parties may decide to exclude any liability for defects of goods, especially when selling used goods or for other reasons, or at least to limit liability for some defects or to limit types of possible claims. Similarly, in mergers and acquisitions, parties very strictly determine what is known by the seller in a disclosure letter and give the buyer access to some information in a data room prior to the conclusion of the contract to limit liability to the unknown and the non-disclosed. CA Hill/BJM Quinn/SD Sollomon, Mergers and Acquisitions, Law, Theory, and Practice (2019) 372–403; R Tschäni/H-J Diem/M Wolf (eds), M&A-Transaktionen nach Schweizer Recht (3rd edn 2021) 209–215 (paras 420–431); O Duys/K Henrich in: W Hölters (ed), Handbuch Unternehmenskauf (8th edn 2015) ch 16, paras 16.108–16.116. For each party, much of contractual drafting boils down to limiting risk to the greatest extent possible, or at least to ensure compensation for any risk incurred. If parties are on an equal footing, this may lead to an equitable allocation of risk and a balanced contractual liability regime. Contractual limitations of liability are, therefore, part of this process of adequate allocation of risks. In this contribution, I will briefly address three issues. First, I will look at which principles are applicable to the validity of limitations of contractual liability (I) and then determine to what extent these principles apply to tort claims (II). This will finally lead me to determine whether the Principles of European Tort Law (PETL) need to be supplemented by a further rule dealing with the validity of contractual clauses limiting liability in tort (III).