‘Constructing a Critical Situation’: A Data-Based Approach to the Study of Cultural Periodicals and Art Criticism

Abstract

The article proposes a three-tier model for the analysis of cultural dynamics of the visual arts field, based on data extracted from cultural periodicals and art criticism. Originally developed on the case study of the visual arts scene in Croatia at the turn of the millennium, the model is flexible and can be applied to analyse the complexity of the art field in different (trans)national spaces and time periods. The article outlines the theoretical foundations of the model, developed at the intersection of (digital) art history, sociology of art, social network analysis and relational sociology, and gives a detailed description of the criteria that were used to define the network boundaries in the original research. The three-tier model foregrounds some of the central actors of the art field, such as cultural periodicals, art critics, artists and cultural institutions, who are approached using both quantitative and qualitative methods. It conceptualizes cultural periodicals and art critics that form part of their networks as sharing aesthetic and ideological values, and as producing specific cultural narratives within the structure of the scene. The analytic potential of the model is focused on determining the cohesiveness of different social circles present in an art scene, on identifying the changing cultural trends and narratives that permeate the field, and on revealing the contribution of different social circles to these network and cultural structures.