Comparison of the Testicular Effects of 2-Methoxyethanol (ME) in Rats and Guinea Pigs

Abstract

Glycol ethers produce both hemato-and testicular toxicity in animals, which is dependent on both the alkyl chain length and animal species used. Ethylene glycol monobutyl ether (2-butoxyethanol, BE) causes hemolytic anemia in rats but not in guinea pigs, and red blood cells from both guinea pigs and humans are minimally affected in vitro by the active metabolite 2-butoxyacetic acid. This demonstrates the importance of animal species selection for assessing human risk to BE exposure. 2-Methoxyethanol (ME) produces testicular lesions in rats characterized primarily by the degeneration of spermatocytes undergoing meiotic division with minimal or no hemolytic changes. Because of the differential hemolytic response to BE between rats and guinea pigs, the present study addressed whether the testicular response to ME was similarly dichotomous. Adult rats or guinea pigs were given a single dose of either 200 or 300 mg ME/kg by gavage, and testicular and hemolytic changes were assessed 24 hr after treatment. Testis histology in rats showed dose-dependent degeneration of dividing spermatocytes in stage XIV tubules as expected, with only minimal hemolytic changes, also as expected. In contrast, no testicular or hemolytic effects were observed in guinea pigs 24 hr after either single ME dose. In a subsequent study, a single dose or multiple (3 daily) doses of 200 mg ME/kg were given, and animals were examined at 4 days after the start of treatment. Testes from rats given both single and multiple ME doses showed, as expected, tubules depleted of spermatocytes and early spermatids. In guinea pigs, spermatocyte degeneration was observed in stage III/IV tubules for both dosing schemes, but was much less severe and widespread and differed from rats in morphological characteristics, specifically in the appearance of nuclear chromatin degeneration. In the rat, degenerating spermatocytes showed uniformly condensed and dispersed chromatin, while in the guinea pig they showed marked chromatin condensation at the nuclear periphery. No hemolytic changes were observed in either species or dosing scheme. In summary, although ME-associated testicular lesions were observed in both species, they differed significantly in onset, characteristics, and severity. Both the nature of the differential testicular response to ME and a comparison to the in vitro human testicular response to the active metabolite 2-methoxyacetic acid are subjects of future study.