Comparison of the Quality of Echocardiography Imaging Between the Left Lateral Decubitus and Supine Positions.

Abstract

Introduction It is commonly taught that positioning the patient in the left lateral decubitus (LLD) position will improve transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) image quality. Despite this, no previous studies have been performed that study this practice. Our goal was to quantify the difference in image quality of TTE views between the supine and LLD positions. Methods This was a prospective study in a single academic Emergency Department (ED) of a convenience sample of 30 patients. Three separate ED physicians performed TTE views in both the supine and LLD position on each patient. The order of position was randomized. Images were then reviewed on a previously validated TTE image quality scale by two blinded ED physicians with specialized training in ultrasound. The scale used a 0 to 5 (highest quality) metric for quality assessment. Interpretability of right ventricular and left ventricular function was also assessed. Results The mean image quality for the supine position was 2.85 (standard deviation {SD} 1.1) and 3.05 (SD 1.2) for the LLD position (p=0.044). In the subset of parasternal and apical windows, the mean quality for the supine position was 2.87 (SD 1.1) and 3.23 (SD 1.1) for the LLD position (p=0.003). The number of studies in which right ventricular function was interpretable was significantly higher in the LLD position (62% versus 42%, p=0.044). Conclusions There was a statistically significant increase in image quality when TTE was performed in the LLD position as compared to supine. This was especially pronounced in the apical four and parasternal windows.