Comparison of short-chain chlorinated paraffin concentrations and homolog profiles by interlaboratory trial using a candidate reference material

Abstract

Listen

Translate article

Chlorinated paraffins (CPs) are industrial chemicals that have been primarily used in applications involving metalworking fluids. Among CPs, short-chain chlorinated paraffins (SCCPs) are a well-known environmental pollutant and are listed under Annex A of the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants. CPs are alkanes substituted with chlorine atoms, and SCCPs are comprised of 10–13 carbon atoms. Reliable quantification of SCCPs is a critical issue because of the large number of SCCP isomers that are in use across multiple industries. Some interlaboratory comparisons of SCCP analyses have been conducted, and the reliability of these results was overwhelmingly determined as inferior to that of comparable PCB and dioxin analyses because of variations in the quality of commercial reagents that were employed as quantification standards. In order to address such inconsistencies, this study endeavored to prepare and evaluate a novel SCCP formulation as a candidate reference material for use as a reliable quantification standard. A subject trial study was hence performed to evaluate methods such as gas- and liquid-chromatography mass spectrometry (GC/MS and LC/MS) on sample matrices (without a clean-up process), and to subsequently elucidate the interpreted specifications for their candidacy as a reliable quantification standard. Results ultimately showed that the SCCP concentrations obtained from GC and LC were comparable. When the homologs reported by a subset of 14 separate laboratories were unified (excluding all results for Cl4 homologs), the carbon chain length profiles obtained from GC and LC were found to be similar; however, the overall chlorine homolog profiles did exhibit slight differences. Moreover, the results from high-resolution MS showed less variation than those from low-resolution MS. Thus, it was overarchingly determined that the deployment of this candidate reference material would serve as an effective mechanism for estimating the comparability of SCCP quantifications/evaluations of standard materials.