Comparison of performances of several FACTS devices using Cuckoo search algorithm optimized 2DOF controllers in multi-area AGC

Abstract

• Comparison of CS algorithm with different versions in 3 area thermal system. • Comparisons of some FACTS devices with best CS optimized 2DOF-IDD controller. • Performance of IPFC with 2DOF-IDD controller reveals the best among all. • Study with placement of IPFC first time in AGC and is best with IPFC in all areas. • Sensitivity analysis reveals robustness of optimum parameters obtained at nominal. This paper presents automatic generation control (AGC) of three unequal area thermal systems with single reheat turbine and appropriate generation rate constraints (GRC) in each area. A two degree of freedom (2DOF) controller called 2DOF-integral plus double derivative (2DOF-IDD) is proposed for the first time in AGC as secondary controller. Secondary controller gains and other parameters are optimized simultaneously using a more recent evolutionary computational technique called Cuckoo Search algorithm (CS). The system dynamic responses for various 2DOF controllers such as 2DOF-PI, 2DOF-PID, and 2DOF-DD are compared. Investigations reveal that responses with 2DOF-IDD are better than others. Performance of several FACTS devices such as Static synchronous series compensator (SSSC), Thyristor controlled series capacitor (TCSC), Thyristor controlled phase shifter (TCPS), and Interline power flow controller (IPFC) in presence of 2DOF-IDD controller are compared and found that the dynamic responses with IPFC are better than others. For the first time in AGC, a case study is performed with placement of IPFC and observed that IPFC present in all three areas of the system performs better. Sensitivity analysis reveals that the CS optimized 2DOF-IDD controller parameters obtained in presence of IPFC in all three areas at nominal condition of loading and size of step load perturbation (SLP) are robust and need not be reset with wide changes in system loading and SLP. Also, the comparison of convergence curve of various algorithms reveals that CS algorithm converges much faster than others.