Comparison of Machine Learning Methods Applied on Multi-Source Medium-Resolution Satellite Images for Chinese Pine (Pinus tabulaeformis) Extraction on Google Earth Engine

Abstract

Chinese pine has tremendous applications in many fields. Mapping the distribution of Chinese pine is of great importance for government decision-making and forest management. In order to extract Chinese pine on a large scale, efficient algorithms and open remote-sensing datasets are needed. It is widely believed that machine learning algorithms and medium-resolution remote-sensing datasets can work well for this purpose. Unfortunately, their performance for Chinese pine extraction has remained unclear until now. Therefore, this study aims to explore the ability of the different machine learning algorithms and open remote-sensing datasets for Chinese pine extraction over large areas on Google Earth Engine (GEE). So, based on the combination of three typical machine learning algorithms, namely deep neural network (DNN), support vector machine (SVM), random forest (RF), and three open medium-resolution remote-sensing datasets, namely Sentinel-2, Gaofen-1, and Landsat-8 OLI, 27 models are constructed and GEE, with its powerful computing ability, is used. The main findings are as follows: (1) DNN has the highest accuracy for Chinese pine extraction, followed by SVM and RF; DNN is more sensitive to spatial geometric information, while SVM and RF algorithms are more sensitive to spectral information. (2) Spectral indexes are helpful for improving the extraction accuracy of Chinese pine. The extraction accuracy by using Gaofen-1 dataset increases 7.6% after adding spectral indexes, while the accuracies by using Sentinel-2 and Landsat-8 datasets increase 1.8% and 1.9% after adding spectral indexes, respectively. (3) The extraction accuracy by using DNN and Sentinel-2 dataset with spectral indexes is the highest, with an overall accuracy of 94.4%. (4) The area of Chinese pine is 153.73 km2, accounting for 5.06% of the administrative area of Karaqin Banner, and it is convenient to extract Chinese pine on a large scale by using GEE.