Comparison and regional suitability evaluation of different backfill source heat pumps using TRNSYS

Abstract

As global energy demand and carbon emissions continues to rise year by year, the use of renewable energy for heating becomes increasingly urgent. This study employs solar and geothermal energy to supply heat to mining facilities. Initially, three distinct heating systems for mining areas were modeled in TRNSYS: the Backfill Source Heat Pump (BSHP), the Solar Assisted Backfill Source Heat Pump (SABSHP), and the Solar Assisted Backfill Source Heat Pump with Seasonal Heat Storage (SABSHP-SHS). Following a decade of simulation, the optimal system was identified through a comparative analysis that encompassed backfill temperature equilibrium, the inlet and outlet water temperatures for buried pipes, Coefficient of Performance (COP), Partial Load Ratio (PLR), and economic factors. Over the 10-year simulation period, the COP and PLR of the SABSHP-SHS system outperformed both the BSHP and SABSHP systems, showing higher energy efficiency and better heat pump performance. To further assess the regional adaptability of the SABSHP-SHS system, simulations were conducted across four regions with diverse climatic profiles: Shijiazhuang, Yan’an, Xining, and Hegang. The analysis focused on heat collection, efficiency, backfill temperature variation, system energy consumption, and the energy efficiency ratio. The findings indicate that Hegang exhibits the highest solar heat collection efficiency at 89.9% during the non-heating season, while Xining achieves a significantly higher heat collection efficiency of 54.1% during the heating season. These results suggest that the SABSHP-SHS system is particularly effective in regions with pronounced seasonal variations, characterized by extended cold winters and brief, intense summers.