Comparing Permeability and Drying Shrinkage of the Concrete Containing Mineral Admixtures under the Equal Strength Grade

Abstract

Fly ash (FA) and ground granulated blast-furnace slag (GGBS) are the most widely used mineral admixtures in engineering. However, their roles in concrete under the equal strength grade, a common comparison method in engineering, were seldom reported. This study investigated the chloride ion permeability and drying shrinkage of concrete samples containing FA or GGBS under an equal strength grade. The samples’ strengths and slumps maintained the same levels by adjusting the water-to-binder ratios and superplasticizer dosages. The results show that both FA and GGBS can promote the resistance to chloride ion penetration and decrease the chloride diffusion coefficients, especially at late ages, due to the hydraulicity of GGBS and pozzolanic activity of FA. Compared with FA, GGBS presents a greater reduction in the concrete permeability due to its higher reactivity. Forty percent replacement levels of FA and GGBS can decrease the penetration level from “high” of plain cement concrete to “moderate” and “low”, respectively. In addition, FA and GGBS can decrease the drying shrinkage of concrete at high replacement levels (30% and 40%). This decrease is more significant in the FA-containing concrete, with the shrinkage decreasing from approximately 400 με to 350 με at a 40% replacement level. The findings can provide scientific guidance for applying FA and GGBS in practical engineering.