Comparative study on biohydrogen production by newly isolated Clostridium butyricum SP4 and Clostridium beijerinckii SP6

Abstract

The hydrogen-producing bacteria SP4 and SP6 were isolated from the compost and identified by 16S rRNA gene sequencing as Clostridium butyricum and Clostridium beijerinckii, respectively. A comparative study on the biohydrogen-producing activity of the isolated strains was carried out using mono-, di- and tri-saccharides belonging to both hexoses (maltose, glucose, mannose, fructose, lactose, galactose, sucrose, raffinose, cellobiose) and pentoses (xylose). To assess the biotechnological significance, real wastewater rich in sugars (cheese whey, confectionery wastewater, sugar beet processing wastewater) was also used as a substrate. C. butyricum SP4 fermented sugars with a yield of 0.93–1.52 mol H2/mol hexose (pentose); the maximum yield was obtained from fructose, the minimum – from raffinose and cellobiose. The most preferred substrate for C. beijerinckii SP6 was sucrose with a yield of 1.76 mol H2/mol hexose, while cellobiose yielded only 0.64 mol H2/mol hexose. Overall, the efficiency of converting wastewater to H2 by C. butyricum SP4 was also slightly lower (66–93 ml H2/g chemical oxygen demand (COD)) than that of C. beijerinckii SP6 (76–103 ml H2/g COD). Even though the main soluble metabolite products (SMPs) for both isolates were acetate and butyrate, C. butyricum SP4 also produced a significant amount of ethanol (up to 21.5% of SMPs) and formate (up to 32.5% of SMPs), and C. beijerinckii SP6 – lactate (up to 25% of SMPs). A distinctive feature of C. beijerinckii SP6 was a significantly lower (almost 2 times) yield of SMPs, while C. butyricum SP4 had a higher rate of H2 production according to the results obtained from the kinetic study using the modified Gompertz equation and the first order equation. Analysis of Spearman's rank correlation coefficients revealed a statistically significant relationship between the kinetic parameters of H2 production and the concentration of butyrate and the final pH of the medium for C. butyricum SP4, and with the concentration of ethanol for C. beijerinckii SP6. These findings provide valuable information on the metabolic capabilities of the most studied hydrogen-producing representatives of the Clostridium genus for their use in optimizing the technology for biohydrogen production by dark fermentation of various organic wastes.