Comparative performance analysis of straight and harped prestressing seven-wire strands: High-strength stainless steel vs. conventional carbon steel

Abstract

This paper presents an experimental investigation into the utilization of high-strength stainless steel (HSSS) strands systems in prestressed bridges. The study delves into the effects of localized bent and harping of seven-wire HSSS strand systems under various harping angles and curvatures produced by the deviators. For comparison purpose, conventional carbon steel (CS) strands were also studied using the same experimental parameters. It was anticipated that CS strands would exhibit better performance due to its superior post-yied ductility. To closely mimic the state of practice in the precast plant, two types of deviators were designed and used in this investigation. A comparable harping capacity was observed for HSSS strands relative to CS strands, despite the CS strands exhibiting higher strain compared to the HSSS strands. Upon reaching their breaking load, necking of all seven wires was predominantly observed for HSSS, whereas the CS strands failed due to the fracture of only one or two outer wires. Due to the lack of ductility in the HSSS stand, it was expected to have the lower bent capacity, especially at higher harping angles. Despite the significant difference in post-yied ductility, the study revealed that both HSSS and CS strands exhibit similar performance. To further understand the similarity and difference in behaviour of these two materials, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) examinations were conducted on both HSSS and CS wires to visualize the bending effects on the microstructure level after bending the center wire at different angles.