Comparative Analysis of Dip-Brazing and TIG Welding on the Properties of Al-64430 Joints

Abstract

This study compares dip brazing and TIG welding operations carried out under optimal conditions on the parameters of strength, deformation, and ability to resist shocks for Al-64430 joints, which find extensive use in automobile and telecommunication industries. The fabricated samples were tested for bump test, surface deformation, microhardness and tensile strength, and the joint properties were studied through SEM, EDAX mapping and EDX. Compared to the dip-brazed samples, the TIG welded samples achieved 161% greater strength and 1000% greater elongation but subsequently 1330% higher surface deformation. Both joints were able to pass the bump test; however, some degree of cracks were observed post testing in both samples. Both samples achieved similar joint microhardness values, but notably, compared with the TIG welded sample, the brazed sample showed no HAZ zones in terms of microhardness variation, where a substantial decrease in microhardness was recorded. This absence of the HAZ region was also confirmed through the microstructure. Both primary and secondary silicon were observed in brazed samples, which had finer grain sizes than did the welded samples. Dendrite formation was observed for the brazed samples, whereas a uniform distribution of aluminium was observed for the welded samples. Fractographic analysis revealed brittle intergranular fracture with small dimples present at the fracture point for the brazed joints, while out-of-plane fracture with sharp edges indicated a more ductile nature for welded joints.