Comparative Analysis and Error Assessment of Nanoindentation Evaluation Techniques for NafionTM117

Abstract

AbstractAdvances in the application of polymers for electrochemical cells require an understanding of their viscous deformation mechanisms and their interaction with moisture. Nanoindentation offers a localized, microscale testing alternative to traditional tensile testing. However, the viscoelastic nature of the polymers, combined with their increased compliance, presents challenges in the analysis of nanoindentation results. In addition, the dependence on moisture results in significant scatter and low repeatability. This study combines nanoindentation and tensile testing as a verification method and compares different correction protocols for static nanoindentation to investigate the mechanical behavior of polymer electrolyte membranes. Comparisons of different indentation devices, analysis methods, and indentation protocols show a significant overestimation of Young’s modulus using the classical Oliver–Pharr method compared to values determined from tensile tests. Nanoindentation at different humidity levels revealed different mechanisms leading to a decrease in Young’s modulus and hardness with increasing humidity.