Combining biotracer and stomach contents analysis to understand trophic dynamics in the northern Gulf of Mexico

Abstract

The northern Gulf of Mexico (nGOM) is a taxonomically rich ecosystem. Previous work based on a meta-analysis of stomach contents data has shown the trophic connectivity of predators and prey to be substantial. However, the trophic dynamics of many economically and ecologically important species are still not well understood. Sportfish, such as Spotted Seatrout (Cynoscion nebulosus), Red Drum (Sciaenops ocellatus), and Southern Flounder (Paralichthys lethostigma), support recreational fisheries throughout the region. Gulf Menhaden (Brevoortia patronus), a high biomass forage fish with the region's largest commercial fishery, is considered an important forage species. In this study, we use information from meta-analysis of stomach contents and stable isotope analysis to investigate the importance of prey taxa, including Gulf Menhaden, for nGOM nearshore predators. Stomach contents and stable isotope analyses are generally evaluated independently, with stomach contents used to directly identify trophic interactions, while stable isotopes of carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) provide insight into a consumer's long-term feeding habits. We used a multispecies trophic model, EcoDiet, developed by Hernvann et al. (2022), that integrates information of both stomach contents and stable isotopes into a single framework to estimate trophic link probabilities and diet proportions. Data in the model include n = 41 predators, n = 173 prey, and n = 497 unique predator and prey interactions. The results indicate that nGOM nearshore predators are generalists using the diverse prey base, and in concordance with previous findings, there is no single Menhaden-dependent predator. Our findings better quantify the trophic interactions of the highly diverse nGOM region and have important implications regarding future ecosystem modeling and management considerations for the Gulf Menhaden stock.