Classicality without local discriminability: Decoupling entanglement and complementarity

Abstract

An operational probabilistic theory where all systems are classical, and all pure states of composite systems are entangled, is constructed. The theory is endowed with a rule for composing an arbitrary number of systems, and with a nontrivial set of transformations. Hence, we demonstrate that the presence of entanglement is independent of the existence of incompatible measurements. We then study a variety of phenomena occurring in the theory -- some of them contradicting both Classical and Quantum Theories -- including: cloning, entanglement swapping, dense coding, additivity of classical capacities, non-monogamous entanglement, hypersignaling. We also prove the existence, in the theory, of a universal processor. The theory is causal and satisfies the no-restriction hypothesis. At the same time, it violates a number of information-theoretic principles enjoyed by Quantum Theory, most notably: local discriminability, purity of parallel composition of states, and purification. Moreover, we introduce an exhaustive procedure to construct generic operational probabilistic theories, and a sufficient set of conditions to verify their consistency. In addition, we prove a characterisation theorem for the parallel composition rules of arbitrary theories, and specialise it to the case of bilocal-tomographic theories. We conclude pointing out some open problems. In particular, on the basis of the fact that every separable state of the theory is a statistical mixture of entangled states, we formulate a no-go conjecture for the existence of a local-realistic ontological model.