Charge transport in protic ionic liquids: Effect of protonation state in 1-methylimidazolium – acetate/trifluoroacetate mixtures

Abstract

Despite the potential to overcome slow charge transport in ionic liquids by decoupling charge transport from mass transport in protic ionic liquids (PILs), the average proton distribution and the contribution of proton conduction to the overall charge transport in PILs has not been fully established. To elucidate the predominant underlying molecular species in the PILs and the molecular dynamics of the PILs, we study the dipolar response and conductivity using dielectric relaxation (DR) spectroscopy and the nucleis chemical environment and molecular mobility using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy of prototypical PILs based on 1–methylimidazolium as Brønsted base. To elucidate the effect of the acidity of the Brønsted acid we gradually vary the composition of the PILs from 1–methylimidazoliumacetate [MimH][AcO] to 1–methylimidazoliumtrifluoroacetate [MimH][TFA]. Both, 15N-NMR chemical shifts and the sample conductivities suggest that in neat [MimH][AcO] electro-neutral molecular species dominate, consistent with earlier findings. The dipolar response of these molecular species as detected via the DR spectra is stronger than what one would expect based on the molecular dipole moments estimated from density functional theory calculations, which points to the formation of an extended hydrogen-bonded network. Upon addition of [MimH][TFA], this dipolar response is reduced as the degree of protonation of 1–methylimidazolium gradually increases, which is apparent from the conductance and 15N chemical shifts. Interestingly, diffusion ordered NMR spectroscopy indicates protons to become more mobile than the constituting acid and base molecules, consistent with Grotthuss-like proton transport. To vary the immediate environment of the PILs, we study solutions of the PIL mixtures in aprotic dimethylformamide (DMF) and protic methanol (MeOH) as two limiting cases. We find that [MimH][AcO] exclusively forms electroneutral species in DMF, as evident from the negligible conductivity, while with increasing TFA content the fraction of charged molecular species increases. Although these ionic species give rise to a finite conductivity, demonstrating the presence of mobile ions, a large fraction of these ions is bound in [MimH][TFA] ion-pairs, as detected in the DR spectra. Yet, temperature dependent 1H-NMR linewidths of the acidic proton signals suggest proton exchange to occur on the NMR timescale, presumably between [MimH]+ and [Mim]. Conversely, in MeOH we find no evidence for the presence of ion-pairs, while the high conductivity of these solutions shows that MeOH can efficiently solvate ions and may participate in proton transfer. Together, our results highlight the sensitivity of protonation equilibria to the immediate environment and of proton dynamics to these protonation equilibria. Our results show that tuning these equilibria using PIL mixtures can provide routes to tailor the contribution of proton transport to charge transport in PILs.