Changes in Monkman-Grant relation among four creep regions of modified 9Cr-1Mo steel

Abstract

The relation of creep rupture life to minimum creep rate, namely Monkman-Grant (MG) relation is examined by using a creep database of modified 9Cr-1Mo steel. The database covers wide ranges of creep rupture life up to 1.2 × 105 h and of minimum creep rate down to 7.6 × 10−8 h−1. The MG plot exhibits a low overall value of MG exponent (p = 0.85) together with wide scatter of data points at long rupture life. Causes of the low p value and the wide scatter are discussed in the present study paying attention to change in creep curve shape with creep rupture life. There are four regions H, M, L1 and L2 showing different creep behavior in the steel. Regional MG relations are examined also in each region. Values of p are less than unity and change among the four regions. The p value is especially low (0.62) in long-term region L2. The regional p values less than unity result in the low overall p value of 0.85. The especially low regional value of p in the long-term region causes the wide scatter of data points in the overall MG plot. A modified Monkman-Grant equation (Eq. (29)) is proposed taking account of creep deceleration rate A (=−1/(dln ε˙/dε), where ε˙ and ε are the creep strain rate and the creep strain) in primary creep and creep acceleration rate B (=1/(dln ε˙/dε)) in tertiary creep. The rates characterize shape of a creep curve. The modified equation can explain the difference of p values among the four regions.