Carryover effects of embryonic hypoxia exposure on adult fitness of the Pacific abalone

Abstract

The widespread and severe drop in dissolved oxygen concentration in the open ocean and coastal waters has attracted much attention, but assessments of the impacts of environmental hypoxia on aquatic organisms have focused primarily on responses to current exposure. Past stress exposure might also affect the performance of aquatic organisms through carryover effects, and whether these effects scale from positive to negative based on exposure degree is unknown. We investigated the carryover effects of varying embryonic hypoxia levels (mediate hypoxia: 3.0−3.1 mg O2/L; severe hypoxia: 2.0−2.1 mg O2/L) on the fitness traits of adult Pacific abalone (Haliotis discus hannai), including growth, hypoxia tolerance, oxygen consumption, ammonia excretion rate, and biochemical responses to acute hypoxia. Moderate embryonic hypoxia exposure significantly improved the hypoxia tolerance of adult Pacific abalone without sacrificing growth and survival. Adult abalone exposed to embryonic hypoxia exhibited physiological plasticity, including decreased oxygen consumption rates under environmental stress, increased basal methylation levels, and a more active response to acute hypoxia, which might support their higher hypoxia tolerance. Thus, moderate oxygen declines in early life have persistent effects on the fitness of abalone even two years later, further affecting population dynamics. The results suggested that incorporating the carryover effects of embryonic hypoxia exposure into genetic breeding programs would be an important step toward rapidly improving the hypoxia tolerance of aquatic animals. The study also inspires the protection of endangered wild animals and other vulnerable species under global climate change.