Bordering on insanity: misnomer, reviewing the case of condemned women

Abstract

In the UK, there have been calls to develop gendered specific mental health services for women in an attempt to ensure privacy and dignity are achieved as and when women come into contact with services. This is a largely rhetorical policy objective. There are more fundamental factors affecting women's experience of mental health services that need addressing. This paper explores these issues in the context of mental health care for women who have been 'given' the diagnosis of borderline personality disorder (BPD). Borderline personality disorder effects 2% of the adult population, 75-90% of those diagnosed being women. This diagnosis continues to present considerable conceptual and therapeutic challenges for all of those involved in mental health services and it remains a categorical label that evokes a wide range of conscious and unconscious responses in mental health nurses. The paper argues that mental health nurses need to recognize the defence mechanisms involved in working with individuals who are often difficult to work with. It is only when mental health nurses can embrace and acknowledge the person in the context of their life, that the pejorative and disabling consequences of the BPD label can be eliminated, ensuring the individual's story is heard and not that which is often a pre-constituted account accompanying this diagnosis.