Bisquaternary caracurine V and iso-caracurine V salts as ligands for the muscle type of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors: SAR and QSAR studies

Abstract

The binding constants (Ki values) of 24 caracurine V and 6 iso-caracurine V analogues for the muscle type of nicotinic ACh receptors (nAChR) from Torpedo californica were determined in a binding assay using (±)-[3H]epibatidine as a radioligand. The allyl alcohol group present in the iso-caracurine V ring system was found to be essential for high binding affinity. The most potent compounds are the dimethyl and di-(4-nitrobenzyl)-iso-caracurinium V salts 29 (18nM), and 31 (79nM), respectively. Compound 29 and the corresponding diallyl analogue 30 (350nM) exhibited similar binding affinities as the equally substituted neuromuscular-blocking agents toxiferine I (14nM) and alcuronium (234nM), respectively. The SAR results were confirmed by QSAR studies, which additionally revealed that the presence of hydrogen-bond acceptor groups close to the quaternary nitrogen, is detrimental for the nicotinic binding affinity. The diallyl- and dimethylcaracurinium V salts 13 and 27, respectively, which are known to be among the most potent allosteric modulators of M2 receptors (EC50=10 and 8nM, respectively), exhibited rather low nicotinic binding affinities for muscle type nAChR (Ki=1.5 and 5.2μM, respectively). Such a large difference in affinity suggests that it is possible to develop compounds with high muscarinic allosteric potency and low or negligible affinities for (α1)2β1γδ nAChR. Additionally, the iso-caracurine V analogues with binding affinities comparable to those of (+)-tubocurarine and alcuronium could become a new class of neuromuscular-blocking agents.