Biomechanical assessment of docking ulnar collateral ligament reconstruction after failed ulnar collateral ligament repair with suture augmentation

Abstract

Ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) repair with single-strand suture augmentation has been introduced as a viable surgical option for throwers with acute UCL tears. For the original single-strand suture augmentation construct, revision UCL reconstructions can be challenging owing to the bone loss at the site of anchor insertion in the center of the sublime tubercle. This biomechanical study assessed a small-diameter (1.5-mm) ulnar bone tunnel technique for double-strand suture-augmented UCL repair that may be more easily converted to salvage UCL reconstruction if necessary, as well as a salvage UCL reconstruction with a docking technique after a failed primary suture-augmented UCL repair. In 7 fresh-frozen cadaveric upper extremities (mean age, 66.3 years), a custom shoulder testing system was used to simulate the late cocking phase of throwing. The elbow valgus opening angle was evaluated using a MicroScribe 3DLX device for sequentially increasing valgus torque (from 0.75 to 7.5 Nm in 0.75-Nm increments) at 90° of flexion. Valgus angular stiffness (in newton-meters per degree) was defined as the correlation of sequentially increasing valgus torque with the valgus opening angle through simple linear regression (slope of valgus torque - valgus opening angle curve). Four conditions were tested: intact elbow, distal UCL avulsion, primary UCL repair with double-strand suture augmentation using small-diameter bone tunnels, and subsequent docking UCL reconstruction in the same specimen. Load-to-failure tests were performed for primary UCL repair with double-strand suture augmentation and subsequent docking UCL reconstruction. With increasing elbow valgus torque, the valgus opening angle increased linearly in each condition (R2 ≥ 0.98, P < .001). Distal UCL avulsion resulted in significantly decreased angular stiffness compared with the intact UCL (P < .001). Both UCL repair with double-strand suture augmentation and subsequent UCL reconstruction showed significantly increased angular stiffness values compared with distal UCL avulsion (P < .001 and P < .001, respectively). On load-to-failure testing, there was no significant difference in stiffness, yield torque, and ultimate torque between the primary suture-augmented UCL repair and the subsequent UCL reconstruction (P = .11, P = .77, and P = .38, respectively). In all specimens undergoing the small-diameter ulnar bone tunnel technique for double-strand suture-augmented UCL repair, failure occurred by retear of the repaired ligament without causing an ulnar bone bridge fracture. Primary UCL repair with double-strand suture augmentation using small-diameter bone tunnels was able to restore valgus stability. When failure occurs, this technique retains enough cortical bone to permit subsequent docking UCL reconstruction.