Bi-attribute utility preference robust optimization: A continuous piecewise linear approximation approach

Abstract

In this paper, we consider a bi-attribute decision making problem where the decision maker’s (DM’s) objective is to maximize the expected utility of outcomes with two attributes but where the true utility function which captures the DM’s risk preference is ambiguous. To tackle this ambiguity, we propose a maximin bi-attribute utility preference robust optimization (BUPRO) model where the optimal decision is based on the worst-case utility function in an ambiguity set of plausible utility functions constructed using partially available information such as the DM’s specific preference for certain lotteries. Specifically, we consider a BUPRO model with two attributes, where the DM’s risk attitude is bivariate risk-averse and the ambiguity set is defined by a linear system of inequalities represented by the Lebesgue–Stieltjes integrals of the DM’s utility functions. To solve the inner infinite-dimensional minimization problem, we propose a continuous piecewise linear approximation approach to approximate the DM’s unknown true utility. Unlike the univariate case, we partition the domain of the utility function into a set of small non-overlapping rectangles and then divide each rectangle into two triangles by either the main diagonal (Type-1) or the counter diagonal (Type-2). The inner minimization problem based on the piecewise linear utility function can be reformulated as a mixed-integer linear program and the outer maximization problem can be solved efficiently by the derivative-free method. In the case that all the small triangles are partitioned either in Type-1 or in Type-2, the inner minimization can be formulated as a finite dimensional linear program and the overall maximin as a single mixed-integer program. To quantify the approximation errors, we derive, under some mild conditions, the error bound for the difference between the BUPRO model and the approximate BUPRO model in terms of the ambiguity set, the optimal value and the optimal solutions. Finally, we carry out some numerical tests to examine the performance of the proposed models and computational schemes. The results demonstrate the efficiency of the computational schemes and highlight the stability of the BUPRO model against data perturbations.