Balancing of total knee arthroplasty by bone cuts achieves accurately balanced soft tissues without the need for soft tissue releases

Abstract

IntroductionPatient satisfaction, after mechanically aligned Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) is only 80%-85%. There is an inabilty to consistently get perfect soft tissue balance with this technique. It is postulated that soft tissue balance within 2° can be achieved by the boney cuts (Bone Balancing) without soft tissue releases, accepting whatever coronal mechanical alignment (CMA) this produces; that the alignment produced would be similar to natural (constitutional) alignment and that balanced knees would improve patient satisfaction.MethodsWe report on 914 consecutive TKAs using Bone Balancing: the femoral rotation for the flexion gap; the distal femoral cut and valgus angle for the extension gap are adjusted to give equal gap sizes with soft tissue balanced within 2° of medio-lateral laxity. Long leg X-rays were used to measure post-operative coronal alignment. Satisfaction beyond 1 year post operation was assessed by an independent researcher, using a question on satisfaction and a VAS score.Results782(85.5%) TKAs with satisfactory x-rays were available at 2-7 years follow up. Their CMA had a similar distribution profile to reported natural alignment studies. Of these, 672 (86%) had a CMA of 0°±3° (’aligned' group). Overall patient satisfaction was 92.8%, with satisfied patients having a mean (range) VAS score of 9.53 (7.3-10.0) and the dissatisfied patients 3.78 (0.0-6.3) (p<0.0001). There was no difference in satisfaction between ’aligned' knees (92.7%) and those ’outliers', whose CMA was >±3° (93.6%) (p=0.853). All balance measurements were within 3° with 92.2% being ≤2°. Gap size difference between extension and 90° flexion was ≤2mm in 98.7% of cases. Midflexion (45° flexion) balance was within 3° in all cases and the gap size difference was ≤2mm in 89%.ConclusionBalancing by bone cuts is able to achieve accurately balanced soft tissues without the need for soft tissue releases. The coronal alignment profile produced matches that of the normal population. This technique improves satisfaction compared to the literature for mechanically aligned TKAs. Acurate and measured soft tissue balancing needs further consideration in TKAs.Level of EvidenceLevel IV.