Axial Chirality of Donor–Donor, Donor–Acceptor, and Tethered 1,1′-Binaphthyls: A Theoretical Revisit with Dynamics Trajectories

Abstract

The circular dichroism (CD) spectra of (R)-2,2'-dimethoxy-1,1'-binaphthyl (DD) and its untethered and tethered donor-acceptor analogues (DA and DA7-DA9) were investigated experimentally and theoretically. The experimental CD spectra of DD and DA resembled each other in several aspects, displaying a positive-positive-negative Cotton effect pattern in the (1)L(b)-(1)L(a) region and a strong negative couplet at the (1)B(b) band, but significantly differed in transition energy and rotatory strength. The couplet amplitude (A) of the main band was 1.6 times larger in DA than in DD, despite the comparable extinction coefficients and seemingly analogous conformations. An additional positive Cotton effect was observed at the CT (CT) band for donor-acceptor binaphthyl DA. Our theoretical prediction of the CD spectra of binaphthyls involves three sequential first principle quantum mechanics (QM) calculations. Thus, the geometry optimizations of a series of conformers with varying dihedral angles were performed by the dispersion-corrected DFT-D method using the B97-D functional and the TZV2P basis set. The potential curve as a function of the dihedral angle (θ) was obtained by using the SCS-MP2/TZVPP single-point energy calculations with and without application of the solvent correction. The CD spectrum of each conformer was independently calculated by the second-order approximate coupled cluster calculation (CC2 method) using the TZVPP basis sets and the resolution of the identity (RI-J) approximation. The (net) theoretical CD spectrum was obtained by averaging over all possible conformers, where the dynamics trajectories based on the relative SCS-MP2 energies were taken into account. By using 17 possible conformers at θ varying from 50 to 130° by 5° intervals, the experimental CD spectra were successfully reproduced in a quantitative manner, enabling us to characterize properly almost all of the important spectral features and chiroptical properties. The two-state model, reported previously, turned out to have led to the right answer with wrong reasons. The couplet sign and amplitude A are critical functions of θ and can be used not only for (qualitatively) determining the absolute configuration but also for quantitatively analyzing the binaphthyl conformations. The angle dependence of A was already argued in the classical coupled oscillator and exciton chirality theories to provide reasonable structure elucidations but only in a qualitative or semiquantitative manner. Our method is able to predict the A value quantitatively as a function of θ. For tethered binaphthyls DA7-DA9, particular care should be exercised in the conformational assessment based on the classical treatment because the amplitude A was shown to be significantly affected by the existence of the tether itself. In the present method, the couplet amplitude A was nicely related to the dihedral angle θ of DA and DD by the state-of-the-art ab initio calculations, enabling us to gain the quantitative information about the conformation of axially chiral binaphthyls. The Cotton effect at the CT band also serves as a complementary clue for elucidating the conformation of donor-acceptor binaphthyls.