Are resting metabolic rate and clinical symptoms affected by variation of serum thyroid stimulating hormone levels within the normal range in healthy and women with hypothyroidism? A case–control study

Abstract

BackgroundIt is unclear whether variation in thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) levels within the reference range affect energy expenditure and clinical symptoms and even within the normal range of TSH levels, resting energy expenditure may alter. The aim of the present study was to determine whether treated hypothyroid subjects and healthy subjects with a low-normal TSH range (0.3–2.3 mIU/L) have better clinical outcomes and increased energy expenditure than those with a high-normal TSH range (2.3–4.3 mIU/L). MethodsThis was a case-control study of 160 overweight/obese women with TSH levels across the reference range of 0.3-4.3 mU/l. Subjects were paired in four groups: healthy subjects with low-normal target TSH (n =40), healthy subjects with high-normal target TSH (n =40), subjects with treated hypothyroidism with low-normal target TSH (n =40), and subjects with treated hypothyroidism with high-normal target TSH (n =40). Resting energy expenditure (RMR), dietary intake, body composition, physical activity, and biochemical markers were assessed. ResultsSubjects with low-normal (≤2.3 mU/L) and high-normal (>2.3 mU/L) TSH levels did not differ in terms of RMR, serum T3 levels, and clinical symptoms except fatigue (P=0.013). However, serum fT4 levels were found to be significantly different between the study groups (P=0.002). Serum fT4 concentration was the highest in subjects with treated hypothyroidism with low-normal target TSH. ConclusionVariation in serum TSH levels within the reference range did not significantly affect REE and clinical symptoms except fatigue in healthy and women with hypothyroidism.