Apatite texture and trace element chemistry of carbonatite-related REE deposits in China: Implications for petrogenesis

Abstract

Apatite is a ubiquitous mineral in carbonatites, and incorporates a variety of trace elements including rare earth elements (REEs). In this study, the textural and chemical variations of apatite were examined in order to trace the magmatic and hydrothermal petrogenesis of three carbonatite-related REE deposits: Shaxiongdong, Miaoya, and Bayan Obo. Various apatite textures were revealed by cathodoluminescence and back-scattered electron imaging. Magmatic apatite, which occurs predominantly in samples from Shaxiongdong, is euhedral, and commonly shows oscillatory or growth zonation with a yellow–green luminescent core and a violet luminescent rim. Euhedral to subhedral metasomatic apatite from Miaoya and Bayan Obo has a turbid texture, with the majority of grains associated with exsolved monazite. Hydrothermal apatite from Bayan Obo, typically occurring as aggregates in close association with fluorite and barite, is anhedral, with green or light violet luminescence.The different apatite textures are characterised by distinct trace element compositions. Magmatic apatite contains the highest concentrations of Mn (avg. 457 ppm) and Sr (avg. 18,285 ppm) and is characterised by a steeply inclined REE chondrite-normalised pattern. Metasomatic apatite, which has undergone in situ dissolution–reprecipitation, contains lower Mn (avg. 272 ppm) and Sr (avg. 9945 ppm) concentrations. It is characterised by highly variable REE trends with an La/SmN ratio varying from 0.13 to 5.61, and lower average La/YbN, La/SmN, and Sr/Y ratios (46, 2.2, and 18, respectively) than magmatic apatite. Hydrothermal apatite that was precipitated from a fluid is characterised by convex upward chondrite-normalised REE distributions with the lowest La/YbN, La/SmN, and Sr/Y ratios (13, 0.69, and 5.8, respectively). The average concentrations of Mn and Sr in this apatite are 270 and 6610 ppm, respectively. There are no Eu anomalies (Eu/Eu* = 0.97) in the chondrite-normalised REE plots for any of the analysed apatite samples. The combined textural and compositional variations of apatite in the three deposits reflect diverse magmatic and hydrothermal processes, including: 1) mineral fractionation contributing to core–rim zoning within the Shaxiongdong magmatic apatite; 2) dissolution–reprecipitation inducing monazite precipitation in Miaoya and Bayan Obo metasomatic apatite; and 3) coprecipitation with fluorite and barite from fluids generating the Bayan Obo hydrothermal apatite.A compilation of published apatite compositions from other rock types demonstrates that trace element compositions of apatite can be used to differentiate crystallisation environments and differentiate apatite from other rock types. Apatite from carbonatite has high Sr, REEs, La/YbN, Th/U, and Sr/Y, and no Eu anomaly, compared with apatite from igneous silicate rocks (except ultramafic rocks), and iron-oxide copper gold (IOCG) or iron-oxide apatite (IOA) deposits.