Aortic valve repair with patch in non-rheumatic disease: indication, techniques and durability

Abstract

Listen

Translate article

To analyse the long-term outcomes of aortic valve (AV) repair with biological patch in patient with non-rheumatic valve disease. From 1995 to 2011, 554 patients underwent elective (AV) repair; among them, 57 (mean age 45 ± 17 years) had cusp restoration using patch for non-rheumatic valve disease. Seven (12%) patients had unicuspid valve, 30 (53%) patients had bicuspid valve and 20 (35%) had tricuspid valve. Autologous pericardium was used in 26 patients (7 treated, 19 non-treated), bovine pericardium in 26, autologous tricuspid valve leaflet in 4 and aortic homograft cusp in 1. Patching was used to repair perforation (n = 20, 35%), commissural defect (n = 18, 32%), raphe repair (n = 17, 30%) or for cusp extension (n = 2, 3.5%). Echocardiographic and clinical follow-up was 98% complete and mean follow-up was 72 ± 42.5 months. No hospital mortality. At 8 years, overall survival was 90 ± 5% and freedom from valve-related death was 96 ± 3%. Two patients (3.5%) needed early reoperation for aortic regurgitation (AR); they underwent re-repair and the Ross procedure, respectively. Late reoperation was necessary in 9 patients (16%) for AR (n = 4), stenosis (n = 3) or mixed disease (n = 2). They had the Ross procedure (n = 6) or prosthetic valve replacement (n = 3) with no mortality. At 8 years, freedom from reoperation was 75 ± 9%. Freedom from reoperation was slightly higher in tricuspid compared with non-tricuspid valves (92 ± 7 vs 68 ± 11%, P = 0.18) and slightly higher for bovine (95 ± 5%) compared with autologous pericardium (73 ± 11%, P = 0.38), but differences were statistically not significant. In tricuspid valves, freedom from reoperation was higher in perforation repair compared with other techniques (100 vs 50 ± 35%, P = 0.02). In bicuspid valves, freedom from reoperation was similar between different repair techniques (P = 0.38). Late echocardiography showed AR 0-1 in 30 (53%) patients, AR 2 in 12 (21%) and no AR ≥ 3. Three patients presented a mean transvalvular gradient of 30-40 mmHg. Thromboembolic events occurred in 2 patients (0.6%/patient-year), bleeding events in 1 (0.3% /patient-year) and no endocarditis occurred. AV repair with biological patch is feasible for various aetiologies. The techniques are safe and medium-term durability is acceptable, even excellent for perforation repair in tricuspid valve morphology. Bovine pericardium is a good alternative to autologous pericardium.