Analysis of long-term effect of juvenile-onset recurrent respiratory papillomatosis

Abstract

Objective: To observe the clinical course of children with juvenile-onset recurrent respiratory papillomatosis (JORRP) until 14 years old. Methods: The clinical data of one hundred and twenty cases treated between Januray 1, 2002 and September 30, 2017 in Beijing Tongren Hospital were analyzed retrospectively. Excluding the deaths and the lost, patients who could be ≥ 5 years without recurrence, were defined as the cured group, and < 5 years with recurrence defined as the recurrent group. Furthermore, using statistical methods to analyze the differences of the age of initial operation, total number of operations, invasive lesion, HPV infection, tracheotomy, airway dissemination after tracheotomy and time of tube wear between the two groups. Results: One hundred and three cases were followed up, except for the six deaths.Numbers of operations in eight cases were ≤2, and ≥3 in eighty nine cases.Peak of the primary surgical age were about 4.5 years old, while the self-healing trend occurred at nine years old. In the cured group, forty three cases were cured, with a curative rate of 41.7% (43/103), and there were all fifty four survivors in the recurrent group.The total number of operations, invasive cases, HPV positive cases and the G score of hoarseness in the recurrent group were higher than those in the cured group (F=13.02, χ(2)=13.04, χ(2)=17.37, Z=-4.59, P<0.05). The number of tracheal dissemination caused by tracheotomy in the recurrent group (66.7%, 27.8%)was more than that in the cured group (χ(2)=16.01, P<0.05). Compared with the time of wearing a tracheostomy tube in cured group, the recurrent group was longer ((3.4±3.1) years vs (8.3±6.7) years, χ(2)=7.19, P<0.05). Conclusions: 41.7% of the patients had no relapse for at least five years.There exsisted differences between the cured and recurrent group in the following aspects: the total numbers of surgery, the agression of the lesions, tracheal intratracheal dissemination after tracheotomy, the time of tracheotomy, the HPV typing and the G grading of hoarseness.