An error components mixed logit with heterogeneity in means and variance for fixed object occupant severity outcomes

Abstract

This paper presents an error components mixed logit with heterogeneity in means and variance to capture the heterogeneous effects of contributing factors on fixed object occupant severity. One year (2021) of crash data on fixed object related crashes in Lubbock County, Texas was analyzed with fixed object details extracted from crash narratives and classified into 11 groupings. Crash data included any fixed object collision occurring at any point in the sequence of crash events (not exclusive to the first harmful event). The random parameters were identified as indicators for occupant involvement in the first harmful crash sequence event, with that event being collision with a fixed object, for possible injury and injury severity outcomes. Heterogeneity in the means of these random parameters was found with respect to six different indicator variables. Additionally, heterogeneity in the variance of the injury random parameter was found with respect to two different indicator variables. Inclusion of two error component nests improved prediction accuracy at the observation level for higher severity outcomes. The findings in this study suggest that fixed object classification types should be explored further in relation to heterogeneous effects on occupant severity outcomes. Furthermore, the findings also highlight the applicability of an error components mixed logit model for severity analysis.