Alternatives to polyethylene mulch film — a field assessment of transported materials in capsicum (Capsicum annuum L.)

Abstract

Materials used as mulches may be either transported to the farm then laid on the soil surface or grown in situ. To assess biodegradable alternatives to non-degradable polyethylene film, the response of capsicum (Capsicum annuum L. cv. Target) grown in soil beds covered with hessian (burlap), hardwood sawdust, sugarcane (Saccharum spp.) trash, paper film, black biodegradable polymer film, white polyethylene film, or left uncovered was investigated in a field trial during the autumn–winter growing season in subtropical Australia. Use of a split-plot design (mulch whole plots with weeded or unweeded subplots) permitted both weed growth and the effect of weed competition on fruit yield to be measured. The presence of substances within the materials that were possibly detrimental to plant growth was assessed in a separate experiment. The weight of marketable fruit was highest for capsicum plants grown in the weeded subplots of biodegradable polymer and polyethylene, although the yields from these subplots were not different from those for plants grown in the weeded subplots of the paper and sawdust or the unweeded subplots of the biodegradable polymer and paper. The reduction in weight of marketable capsicum fruit from weed competition was ranked for the various mulch treatments as follows: paper < biodegradable polymer < cane trash < polyethylene < hessian < sawdust < bare soil. More hours at optimum soil temperature for root growth (18.9–30˚C) before canopy closure probably accounted for the variation in marketable yield of the capsicum crop. Results from the mulch toxicity experiment indicated that the mulch materials were unlikely to contain phytotoxic substances. Provided the practical difficulties of laying paper film can be overcome and the high cost of biodegradable polymer is reduced, these materials appear to be the best of the biodegradable alternatives tested to polyethylene film.