Agonist efficiency from concentration-response curves: Structural implications and applications

Abstract

Agonists are evaluated by a concentration-response curve (CRC), with a midpoint (EC50) that indicates potency, a high-concentration asymptote that indicates efficacy, and a low-concentration asymptote that indicates constitutive activity. A third agonist attribute, efficiency (η), is the fraction of binding energy that is applied to the conformational change that activates the receptor. We show that η can be calculated from EC50 and the asymptotes of a CRC derived from either single-channel or whole-cell responses. For 20 agonists of skeletal muscle nicotinic receptors, the distribution of η-values is bimodal with population means at 51% (including acetylcholine, nornicotine, and dimethylphenylpiperazinium) and 40% (including epibatidine, varenicline, and cytisine). The value of η is related inversely to the size of the agonist’s headgroup, with high- versus low-efficiency ligands having an average volume of 70 vs. 102 Å3. Most binding site mutations have only a small effect on acetylcholine efficiency, except for αY190A (35%), αW149A (60%), and those at αG153 (42%). If η is known, the EC50 and high-concentration asymptote can be calculated from each other. Hence, an entire CRC can be estimated from the response to a single agonist concentration, and efficacy can be estimated from EC50 of a CRC that has been normalized to 1. Given η, the level of constitutive activity can be estimated from a single CRC.