Affinity of the Highly Preorganized Ligand PDA (1,10-Phenanthroline-2,9-dicarboxylic acid) for Large Metal Ions of Higher Charge. A Crystallographic and Thermodynamic Study of PDA Complexes of Thorium(IV) and the Uranyl(VI) ion

Abstract

The hydrothermal synthesis and structures of [UO2(PDA)] (1) and [Th(PDA)2(H2O)2].H2O (2) (PDA = 1,10-phenanthroline-2,9-dicarboxylic acid) are reported. 1 is orthorhombic, Pnma, a = 11.1318(7) A, b = 6.6926(4) A, c = 17.3114(12) A, V = 1289.71(14), Z = 4, R = 0.0313; 2 is triclinic, P1, a = 7.6190(15) A, b = 10.423(2) A, c = 17.367(4) A, alpha = 94.93(3) degrees , beta = 97.57(3) degrees , gamma = 109.26(3) degrees , V = 1278.3(4) A (3), Z = 2, R = 0.0654. The local geometry around the U in 1 is a pentagonal bipyramid with the two uranyl oxygens occupying the apical positions. The donor atoms in the plane comprise the four donor atoms from the PDA ligand (average U-N = 2.558 and U-O = 2.351 A) with the fifth site occupied by a bridging carboxylate oxygen from a neighboring UO2/PDA individual. The PDA ligand in 1 is exactly planar, with the U lying in the plane of the ligand. The latter planarity, as well as the near-ideal U-O and U-N bond lengths, and O-U-N and N-U-N bond angles within the chelate rings of 1 suggest that PDA binds to the uranyl cation in a low-strain manner. In 2, there are two PDA ligands bound to the Th (average Th-N = 2.694 and Th-O = 2.430 A) as well as two water molecules (Th-O = 2.473 and 2.532 A) to give the Th a coordination number of 10. The PDA ligands in 2 are bowed, with the Th lying out of the plane of the ligand. Molecular mechanics calculations suggest that the distortion of the PDA ligands in 2 arises because of steric crowding. UV spectroscopic studies of solutions containing 1:1 ratios of PDA and Th(4+) in 0.1 M NaClO4 at 25 degrees C indicate that log K1 for the Th(4+)/PDA complex is 25.7(9). The latter result confirms the previous prediction that complexes of PDA with metal ions of higher charge and an ionic radius of about 1.0 A such as Th(IV) would have remarkably high log K1 values with PDA. The origins of this very high stability are discussed in terms of a synergy between the pyridyl and the carboxylate donor groups of PDA. Metal ions of high charge normally bond poorly with pyridyl donors in aqueous solution because such metal ions require donor groups that are able to disperse charge to the solvent via hydrogen-bonding, which pyridyl groups are unable to do. In PDA, the carboxylates fulfill this need and so enable the high donor strength of the pyridyl groups of PDA to become apparent in the high log K1 for Th(IV) with PDA.