Abstract

In 1971, Wolfgang Müller-Lauter introduced his study of Nietzsche as an investigation into the history of modern nihilism in which “contradiction” forms the central thread of the argument. For Müller-Lauter, the interpretive task is not to demonstrate the overall coherence or incoherence of Nietzsche’s philosophy, but to examine Nietzsche’s “philosophy of contradiction.” Against those such as Karl Jaspers, Karl Löwith and Martin Heidegger, Müller-Lauter argued that contradiction is the foundation of Nietzsche’s thought, and not a problem to be corrected or cast aside for exegetical or political purposes. For Müller-Lauter, contradiction qua incompatibility (not just mere opposition) holds a key to Nietzsche’s affective vision of philosophy. Beginning with the relationship between will to power and eternal recurrence, in this paper I examine aspects of Müller-Lauter’s account of Nietzsche’s philosophy of contradiction specifically in relation to the counter-interpretations offered by two other German commentators of Nietzsche, Leo Strauss and Karl Löwith, in order to confirm Müller-Lauter’s suggestion that contradiction is indeed an operative engine of Nietzsche’s thought. Indeed contradiction is a key Nietzschean theme and an important dynamic of becoming which enables the subject to be revealed as a “multiplicity” (BGE §12) and as a “fiction” (KSA 12:9[91]). Following Müller-Lauter’s assertion that for Nietzsche the problem of nihilism is fundamentally synonymous with the struggle of contradiction experienced by will to power, this paper interprets Nietzsche’s philosophy of contradiction in terms of subjective, bodily life (rather than in terms of logical incoherences or ontological inconsistencies). Against the backdrop of nihilism, the “self” (and its related place holder the “subject”), I will argue, becomes the psycho-physiological battlespace for the struggle and articulation of “contradiction” in Nietzsche’s thought.

Highlights

  • In 1971, Wolfgang Müller-Lauter introduced his study of Nietzsche as an investigation into the history of modern nihilism in which “contradiction” forms the central thread of the argument.1 While there are significant contradictions in Nietzsche‟s work as a whole, Müller-Lauter claimed, these tensions relate to and reflect what Nietzsche believes is “contradictory” in the modern experience of existence

  • In this paper, beginning with the relationship between will to power and eternal recurrence, I examine aspects of Müller-Lauter‟s account of Nietzsche‟s philosophy of contradiction in relation to the counter-interpretations offered by two other German commentators of Nietzsche—Leo Strauss and Karl Löwith—in order to confirm Müller-Lauter‟s suggestion that contradiction is an operative engine of Nietzsche‟s thought

  • Following Müller-Lauter‟s assertion that for Nietzsche the problem of nihilism is fundamentally synonymous with the struggle of contradiction experienced by will to power (5), this paper interprets Nietzsche‟s philosophy of contradiction in terms of subjective, bodily life, rather than in terms of logical incoherencies or ontological inconsistencies

Read more

Summary

Introduction

In 1971, Wolfgang Müller-Lauter introduced his study of Nietzsche as an investigation into the history of modern nihilism in which “contradiction” forms the central thread of the argument.1 While there are significant contradictions in Nietzsche‟s work as a whole, Müller-Lauter claimed, these tensions relate to and reflect what Nietzsche believes is “contradictory” in the modern experience of existence. Following Müller-Lauter‟s assertion that for Nietzsche the problem of nihilism is fundamentally synonymous with the struggle of contradiction experienced by will to power (5), this paper interprets Nietzsche‟s philosophy of contradiction in terms of subjective, bodily life, rather than in terms of logical incoherencies or ontological inconsistencies.

Results
Conclusion
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call