A novel framework for interpreting pyrite-based Fe isotope records of the past

Abstract

Abstract The variation in the iron isotopic composition (δ56Fe) of sedimentary pyrite is often interpreted to reflect the degree of Fe redox cycling in modern and ancient environments. However, the degree to which precipitation pathways, isotopic exchange, and precipitation rates can affect the isotopic fractionation associated with pyrite precipitation from aqueous Fe(II) (Fe(II)aq) is poorly understood. In this study, pyrite is precipitated at 80 °C in batch reactors through the H2S and polysulfide pathways, in which the precipitation rates and the concurrent formation of a greigite (Fe3S4) phase is modulated by the amount of initially added elemental sulfur and aqueous molybdenum. Our results indicate an average apparent isotopic fractionation (δ56Fepyrite - δ56FeFeSx, where FeSx includes FeS, Fe(II)aq, and greigite) of −0.51 ± 0.22‰ throughout the experiments irrespective of precipitation pathways and greigite formation. Early-stage precipitation is associated with ∼0.3‰ larger isotopic fractionation than late-stage precipitation, possibly indicating either a rate-dependent kinetic isotope effect (KIE) or a different isotopic fractionation factor for early-stage pyrite nucleation compared to later-stage growth. Overall, the magnitude of the apparent isotopic fractionation is significantly smaller than the