A discourse analysis of General Medical Council (GMC) guidelines for the inclusion of cultural diversity issues in medical education and practice

Abstract

Background Several studies have highlighted the insufficient inclusion of cultural diversity in medical schools’ curricula and the extent of health inequalities highlighted by the COVID-19 pandemic. This study aimed to critically review a range of GMC publications to identify the inclusion of cultural diversity topics in their guidelines, as according to recent studies, doctors are inadequately prepared to serve a diverse population. Methods Twenty-four relevant GMC publications were analysed. An inductive thematic analysis was conducted to review the content of the guidelines; and discourse analysis was used to critically understand the linguistics used whilst also considering the cultural and social context. Results The GMC publications primarily focused on discouraging discrimination and promoting equality. Themes around diversity in medical practice were less commonly covered. There was considerable internal inconsistency across the guidelines. Guidelines aimed at medical schools and medical students were more likely to consider cultural diversity issues compared to those intended for doctors. Conclusions Cultural diversity teaching can only be as effective as the policy that drives it. Despite the inclusion of cultural diversity issues in GMC guidelines, this study suggests considerable ambiguity in how these issues are represented and understood. The guidelines require careful revision and should be written to reduce the likelihood of variable interpretation, thereby promoting better cultural diversity inclusion in medical schools’ curricula, and consequently better patient care.