Abstract
In 2017 the Japanese government reported that its state-owned mining company had successfully extracted zinc from the seabed off the coast of Okinawa. This piloting of technology is currently the world's only example of large-scale extractive activity operating at such depths. Alongside Japan's innovations, the global deep sea mining (DSM) industry is moving towards commercial viability. This paper draws upon critical theoretical perspectives to better understand the complex debates being provoked. While there has been an increasing range of scholarship focusing on DSM from both the natural and social sciences, this paper cautions that the social sciences are not merely tools for assessing public and stakeholder acceptability. They require and deserve a central role in defining the purpose, nature and scope of commercial DSM. This paper therefore develops an approach that seeks to diversify and broaden engagements with DSM and that is well-placed to navigate the political questions that emerge from mining on the seabed. These perspectives also enable us to interrogate claims that DSM offers greater ‘sustainability’ than terrestrial mining does. This paper's interdisciplinary approach draws on empirical reference to, and examples from, the Japanese context, highlighting four main areas of concern for DSM: geography, geopolitics, law and political economy. These areas of critical enquiry reveal DSM's complexities and caution against perceiving DSM as a singular phenomenon. The emergent complex and multi-scalar questions from seabed mining therefore require a more holistic approach. Mining the seabed produces, and is underpinned by, a multitude of social, cultural and political dimensions and the potential consequences of DSM will not be experienced evenly. As this paper demonstrates, DSM is an interdisciplinary issue. The confines of disciplinary norms must therefore be exceeded to facilitate a deeper understanding of both the practices of DSM and their consequences.
Highlights
In late 2017, it was widely reported by the Japanese government that its state-owned mining company – Japan Oil, Gas and Metals National Corporation (JOGMEC) – had successfully extracted zinc from the seabed 1,600 m deep off the coast of Okinawa
We have highlighted the importance of considering the social sciences in discussions on deep sea mining (DSM) and in blurring the disciplinary ‘edges’ that come to define its place within contemporary scholarship
With DSM moving towards commercial viability, critical engagement with this emerging practice must go beyond the usual treatment given to understanding mining on the seabed, which is often centred upon questions of stakeholder perceptions and social licencing
Summary
In late 2017, it was widely reported by the Japanese government that its state-owned mining company – Japan Oil, Gas and Metals National Corporation (JOGMEC) – had successfully extracted zinc from the seabed 1,600 m deep off the coast of Okinawa. There is a need to draw upon critical theoretical perspectives to better understand the complex debates being provoked This is necessary in order to analyse the competing narratives of DSM and its practices across different sites and scales (local, national and global). We aim to incorporate these conceptual aspects into an approach that is better attuned to apprehending DSM and which offers a means to go beyond the usual treatment given to understanding DSM by both the social sciences (which focus on stakeholders, cost-effectiveness, Environ mental Impact Assessments (EIAs) and discussions of the ‘precautionary principle’) and the natural sciences (and their focus on technology development and environmental impacts) These are impor tant, but miss some crucial perspectives found in the literature on resource politics more generally. Ocean and Coastal Management 193 (2020) 105242 a critical approach for thinking about their provocations
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a callDisclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.
