A comparative study on the efficacy of dual-pol and full-pol ASAR data in radiative transfer modeling for forest above-ground biomass estimation

Abstract

ABSTRACT In this study, a comprehensive evaluation of the potential of dual-polarization and full-polarization L- and S-band airborne SAR (LS-ASAR) data (ISRO’s dual-frequency airborne SAR mounted on NASA’s Gulfstream III aircraft) in forest above-ground biomass (AGB) estimation has been carried out. The study area comprises the temperate forests of the Lenoir landing site in Southwest Alabama, United States of America. A trunk scattering model based on Vector Radiative Transfer (VRT) theory is used in this study to estimate the AGB. Full-polarization ASAR data inversion retrieves three critical biophysical parameters: tree height, diameter at breast height (DBH), and tree count, whereas with dual-polarization ASAR data, the model is limited to retrieving only two parameters (tree height and DBH). These parameters are then employed in a suitable allometric equation to estimate the AGB over the study area. Validation of the retrieval results is performed through comparison with ground-truth measurements taken from the study site. The findings demonstrate that the inversion of L-band full-polarized data yields the highest correlation (R2 = 0.87, RMSE = 20.37 t/ha), revealing high accuracy in AGB estimation. The L-band dual-polarized data shows a high correlation (R2 = 0.83, RMSE = 30.66 t/ha), indicating reasonable accuracy. However, the S-band data, both full and dual-polarized, reveals weaker correlations with higher RMSE values (R2 = 0.59, RMSE = 55.07 t/ha, and R2 = 0.49, RMSE = 58.31 t/ha, respectively), suggesting a lower degree of reliability. This study emphasizes the pre-eminence of L-band fully polarized data inversion for reliable and accurate AGB estimation while also showing the utility of relatively ubiquitous dual-pol data (L-band) to achieve reasonable accuracy for the same.