A case for the standardization of protocols used in screening cowpea, Vigna unguiculata for resistance to Callosobruchus maculatus (Fabricius) (Coleoptera: Bruchidae)

Abstract

Cowpea cultivars Ife Brown, Maiduguri-A, Maiduguri-B and TVu 2027, were screened for resistance to Callosobruchus maculatus (F.) attack using different seed and insect densities. The number of eggs laid on the seeds and most other demographic variables increased with increase in insect density (number of females per 40 seeds). Although the same trend was observed with increase in seed density (seeds per 8 females), this was less predictable. However, the number of eggs per seed decreased significantly as seed density increased, but increased with increase in female density. Adult emergence increased significantly with increase in both insect and seed density while the growth index did not vary. Significantly more eggs were laid on the seeds of TVu 2027 (the resistant control) than on all the other cultivars when 20 or 40 seeds were available to 8 females, or at the lowest insect density (2 females per 40 seeds). However, percentage adult emergence and growth were higher on Ife Brown (susceptible control) than on TVu 2027 and the two Maiduguri cultivars. Measurements of percentage adult emergence and growth index indicated clear cultivar differences at all seed and insect densities. Also, although the loss in weight of seed increased with increase in insect density and decreased significantly with increase in seed density, meaningful differences in resistance among test cultivars were not always apparent at all densities. Based on these findings, we propose using 40 seeds and 2 pairs of adult beetles in screening cowpea for resistance. In addition, we conclude that % adult emergence, growth index and % weight loss are the most reliable indicators for resistance of cowpea to damage by this insect. The need to standardize experimental procedures used for host plant resistance work on storage pests of cowpea is emphasized.