Twelve unbridged metallocene dichloride complexes of the types [1-(4-XC6H4SiMe2)-η5-Ind]2MCl2 and [2-(4-XC6H4SiMe2)-η5-Ind]2MCl2 (X=Me, MeO, F; M=Zr, Hf) with differently 1- and 2-substituted indenyl ligands have been synthesized, characterized and applied for catalytic ethylene polymerization. After activation with methylaluminoxane (MAO), all complexes are catalysts for ethylene polymerization. However, in nearly all cases, the species with the silyl substituent in the 1-position show much higher activities than those with the same substituent in 2-position of the indenyl moiety. For instance, the MAO activated complex bis(η5-1-(dimethyl-4-tolylsilyl)idenyl) zirconium(IV) dichloride (3), displayed an almost five times higher activity (3980kg PE/mol cat.h) than the isomeric bis(η5-2-(dimethyl-4-tolylsilyl)indenyl) zirconium(IV) dichloride (19)/MAO catalyst (870kg PE/mol cat.h). The same trend was observed for the para-fluorophenyl silyl indenyl complexes 23 and 17. This behavior may be explained in a way that the same silyl substituent in position 2 can exert more steric hindrance around the metal center compared to the 1-substituted analogues. The GPC characterization of the produced polyethylenes showed that some of the resins have a bimodal molecular weight distribution indicating at least two different active sites that are involved in the polymerization process.