In 1988, the Journal of Criminal Justice published the results of David Twain's 1983–1984 process evaluation of Newark, NJ, Juvenile Conference Committees (JCCs)a volunteer-led, diversionary court program for youth misdemeanor offenders. The authors describe conspicuous inadequacies in the JCC process, in particular the lack of follow-up with juveniles about future recidivist behavior. This article discusses (1) the lack of response by the New Jersey Administrative Office of the Courts to Twain's results, (2) the findings of a 1978 OJJDP report on the effectiveness of JCCs and other volunteer-run juvenile court programs, and (3) an unpublished two-year study of JCC youth recidivism in one New Jersey County. To date, there has never been a published systematic, statewide assessment of conference committees' impact on youth attitudes, behaviors, and norms. This essay proposes ways to measure JCC effectiveness in changing young people's illegal behavior.
Read full abstract