XY Chromatin Research Articles

UHRF1 is indispensable for meiotic sex chromosome inactivation and interacts with the DNA damage response pathway in mice†.

During male meiosis, the constitutively unsynapsed XY chromosomes undergo meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI), and the DNA damage response (DDR) pathway is critical for MSCI establishment. Our previous study showed that UHRF1 (ubiquitin-like, with PHD and ring finger domains 1) deletion led to meiotic arrest and male infertility; however, the underlying mechanisms of UHRF1 in the regulation of meiosis remain unclear. Here, we report that UHRF1 is required for MSCI and cooperates with the DDR pathway in male meiosis. UHRF1-deficient spermatocytes display aberrant pairing and synapsis of homologous chromosomes during the pachytene stage. In addition, UHRF1 deficiency leads to aberrant recruitment of ATR and FANCD2 on the sex chromosomes and disrupts the diffusion of ATR to the XY chromatin. Furthermore, we show that UHRF1 acts as a cofactor of BRCA1 to facilitate the recruitment of DDR factors onto sex chromosomes for MSCI establishment. Accordingly, deletion of UHRF1 leads to the failure of meiotic silencing on sex chromosomes, resulting in meiotic arrest. In addition to our previous findings, the present study reveals that UHRF1 participates in MSCI, ensuring the progression of male meiosis. This suggests a multifunctional role of UHRF1 in the male germline.

Conditional ablation of Raptor in the male germline causes infertility due to meiotic arrest and impaired inactivation of sex chromosomes

Rapamycin is a clinically important drug that is used in transplantation and cancer therapy but which causes a number of side effects, including male infertility. Its canonical target, mammalian target of rapamycin complex 1 (mTORC1), plays a key role in metabolism and binds chromatin; however, its precise role in the male germline has not been elucidated. Here, we inactivate the core component, Raptor, to show that mTORC1 function is critical for male meiosis and the inactivation of sex chromosomes. Disruption of the Raptor gene impairs chromosomal synapsis and prevents the efficient spreading of silencing factors into the XY chromatin. Accordingly, mRNA for XY-linked genes remains inappropriately expressed in Raptor-deficient mice. Molecularly, the failure to suppress gene expression corresponded with deficiencies in 2 repressive chromatin markers, H3K9 dimethylation and H3K9 trimethylation, in the XY body. Together, these results demonstrate that mTORC1 has an essential role in the meiotic progression and silencing of sex chromosomes in the male germline, which may explain the infertility that has been associated with such inhibitors as rapamycin.-Xiong, M., Zhu, Z., Tian, S., Zhu, R., Bai, S., Fu, K., Davis, J. G., Sun, Z., Baur, J. A., Zheng, K., Ye, L. Conditional ablation of Raptor in the male germline causes infertility due to meiotic arrest and impaired inactivation of sex chromosomes.

RNA binding protein Musashi-1 directly targets Msi2 and Erh during early testis germ cell development and interacts with IPO5 upon translocation to the nucleus.

Controlled gene regulation during gamete development is vital for maintaining reproductive potential. During the process of gamete development, male germ cells experience extended periods of inactive transcription despite requirements for continued growth and differentiation. Spermatogenesis therefore provides an ideal model to study the effects of posttranscriptional control on gene regulation. During spermatogenesis posttranscriptional regulation is orchestrated by abundantly expressed RNA-binding proteins. One such group of RNA-binding proteins is the Musashi family, previously identified as a critical regulator of testis germ cell development and meiosis in Drosophila and also shown to be vital to sperm development and reproductive potential in the mouse. We focus in depth on the role and function of the vertebrate Musashi ortholog Musashi-1 (MSI1). Through detailed expression studies and utilizing our novel transgenic Msi1 testis-specific overexpression model, we have identified 2 unique RNA-binding targets of MSI1 in spermatogonia, Msi2 and Erh, and have demonstrated a role for MSI1 in translational regulation. We have also provided evidence to suggest that nuclear import protein, IPO5, facilitates the nuclear translocation of MSI1 to the transcriptionally silenced XY chromatin domain in meiotic pachytene spermatocytes, resulting in the release of MSI1 RNA-binding targets. This firmly establishes MSI1 as a master regulator of posttranscriptional control during early spermatogenesis and highlights the significance of the subcellular localization of RNA binding proteins in relation to their function.

Polycomb Protein SCML2 Associates with USP7 and Counteracts Histone H2A Ubiquitination in the XY Chromatin during Male Meiosis

Polycomb group proteins mediate transcriptional silencing in diverse developmental processes. Sex chromosomes undergo chromosome-wide transcription silencing during male meiosis. Here we report that mouse SCML2 (Sex comb on midleg-like 2), an X chromosome-encoded polycomb protein, is specifically expressed in germ cells, including spermatogonia, spermatocytes, and round spermatids. SCML2 associates with phosphorylated H2AX and localizes to the XY body in spermatocytes. Loss of SCML2 in mice causes defective spermatogenesis, resulting in sharply reduced sperm production. SCML2 interacts with and recruits a deubiquitinase, USP7, to the XY body in spermatocytes. In the absence of SCML2, USP7 fails to accumulate on the XY body, whereas H2A monoubiquitination is dramatically augmented in the XY chromatin. Our results demonstrate that the SCML2/USP7 complex constitutes a novel molecular pathway in modulating the epigenetic state of sex chromosomes during male meiosis.

Class switching and meiotic defects in mice lacking the E3 ubiquitin ligase RNF8

53BP1 is a well-known mediator of the cellular response to DNA damage. Two alternative mechanisms have been proposed to explain 53BP1’s interaction with DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), one by binding to methylated histones and the other via an RNF8 E3 ligase–dependent ubiquitylation pathway. The formation of RNF8 and 53BP1 irradiation-induced foci are both dependent on histone H2AX. To evaluate the contribution of the RNF8-dependent pathway to 53BP1 function, we generated RNF8 knockout mice. We report that RNF8 deficiency results in defective class switch recombination (CSR) and accumulation of unresolved immunoglobulin heavy chain–associated DSBs. The CSR DSB repair defect is milder than that observed in the absence of 53BP1 but similar to that found in H2AX−/− mice. Moreover, similar to H2AX but different from 53BP1 deficiency, RNF8−/− males are sterile, and this is associated with defective ubiquitylation of the XY chromatin. Combined loss of H2AX and RNF8 does not cause further impairment in CSR, demonstrating that the two genes function epistatically. Importantly, although 53BP1 foci formation is RNF8 dependent, its binding to chromatin is preserved in the absence of RNF8. This suggests a two-step mechanism for 53BP1 association with chromatin in which constitutive loading is dependent on interactions with methylated histones, whereas DNA damage–inducible RNF8-dependent ubiquitylation allows its accumulation at damaged chromatin.

Mammalian Polycomb Scmh1 mediates exclusion of Polycomb complexes from the XY body in the pachytene spermatocytes

The product of the Scmh1 gene, a mammalian homolog of Drosophila Sex comb on midleg, is a constituent of the mammalian Polycomb repressive complexes 1 (Prc1). We have identified Scmh1 as an indispensable component of the Prc1. During progression through pachytene, Scmh1 was shown to be excluded from the XY body at late pachytene, together with other Prc1 components such as Phc1, Phc2, Rnf110 (Pcgf2), Bmi1 and Cbx2. We have identified the role of Scmh1 in mediating the survival of late pachytene spermatocytes. Apoptotic elimination of Scmh1(-/-) spermatocytes is accompanied by the preceding failure of several specific chromatin modifications at the XY body, whereas synapsis of homologous autosomes is not affected. It is therefore suggested that Scmh1 is involved in regulating the sequential changes in chromatin modifications at the XY chromatin domain of the pachytene spermatocytes. Restoration of defects in Scmh1(-/-) spermatocytes by Phc2 mutation indicates that Scmh1 exerts its molecular functions via its interaction with Prc1. Therefore, for the first time, we are able to indicate a functional involvement of Prc1 during the meiotic prophase of male germ cells and a regulatory role of Scmh1 for Prc1, which involves sex chromosomes.

XMR, a dual location protein in the XY pair and in its associated nucleolus in mouse spermatocytes

Xlr and Xmr are sex-specific genes which are expressed during the meiotic prophase I in the mouse. In spermatocytes, XMR concentrates on the asynapsed regions of the XY chromosomes, suggesting that XMR plays a role in sex chromosome condensation and silencing. The present study shows that in the mouse, XMR also concentrates in the nucleolus which is closely associated with the XY chromosome pair. In this species, the formation of a large fibrillo-granular nucleolus signals the activation of the ribosomal genes, but release of pre-ribosomal particles is inhibited. Using laser confocal microscopy we characterized the distribution of XMR in the XY body relative to the XY chromatin and the nucleolus. Immunoelectron microscopy showed that XMR concentrates in the fibrillo-granular component and the granular component (GC) of the nucleolus. In (T[X;16]16H) mouse spermatocytes, the nucleolus displays little or no activity and does not associate with the XY pair. XMR concentrated only on the XY chromosomes in (T[X;16]16H) mouse spermatocytes. These data suggest that XMR could play a role both in the XY pair and the nucleolus associated to the sex chromosomes.

BRCA1, Histone H2AX Phosphorylation, and Male Meiotic Sex Chromosome Inactivation

In mammalian spermatogenesis, the X and Y chromosomes are transcriptionally silenced during the pachytene stage of meiotic prophase (meiotic sex chromosome inactivation, MSCI), forming a condensed chromatin domain termed the sex or XY body. The nucleosomal core histone H2AX is phosphorylated within the XY chromatin domain just prior to MSCI, and it has been hypothesized that this triggers the chromatin condensation and transcriptional repression. Here, we show that the kinase ATR localizes to XY chromatin at the onset of MSCI and that this localization is disrupted in mice with a mutant form of the tumor suppressor protein BRCA1. In the mutant pachytene cells, ATR is usually present at nonsex chromosomal sites, where it colocalizes with aberrant sites of H2AX phosphorylation; in these cells, there is MSCI failure. In rare pachytene cells, ATR does locate to XY chromatin, H2AX is then phosphorylated, a sex body forms, and MSCI ensues. These observations highlight an important role for BRCA1 in recruiting the kinase ATR to XY chromatin at the onset of MSCI and provide compelling evidence that it is ATR that phosphorylates H2AX and triggers MSCI.

Nuclear architecture of human pachytene spermatocytes: quantitative analysis of associations between nucleolar and XY bivalents

Nucleolar association and heterochromatin coalescence have both been invoked as mechanisms involved in the origin of chromosomal associations between nucleolar bivalents themselves, as well as between these bivalents and the XY pair, during meiotic prophase in human spermatocytes. However, these mechanisms do not satisfactorily explain how associating bivalents meet each other within the nuclear space. To elucidate this problem, we have characterized different types of nucleolar-nucleolar and nucleolar-XY bivalent associations, and their frequencies, in light and electron microscope serial sections of spermatocyte nuclei. In the pachytene nucleus, nucleolar bivalent associations were found to involve only one nucleolar sphere of RNP granules connected through a fibrillar center to a chromatin mass composed of two, or more, nucleolar-bivalent short arms. Structural relationships between these elements were examined using 3D computer models of various nucleolar associations. XY and nucleolar bivalents were usually located towards the nuclear periphery associated with the inner face of the nuclear envelope. Some nucleolar bivalents, whether single or associated appeared beside or over XY chromatin. When nucleolar-bivalent short arms (BK) were found over nucleolar or over XY chromatin, their telomeres were unattached to the nuclear envelope and the corresponding synaptonemal complexes were not observed. Ninety nucleoli were found in sixty pachytene nuclei. Thirty six percent of these nucleoli were bound to associated BKs and the remaining 64% to single BKs. Over 40% of individual spermatocytes showed at least one cluster of associated BKs and about 20% presented single or multiple BKs associated with the XY pair. The frequencies of random BK associations, over the total or restricted areas of the nuclear envelope, were calculated according to a probabilistic nuclear model. A correspondence was found in comparing the observed frequencies of associated BKs with those calculated on the basis of bouquet formation. Such an analysis strongly suggests that the occurrence of associations between nucleolar bivalents may arise at random within the bouquet. Thus, the architecture of the meiocyte nucleus, particularly the organization of the bouquet, may be the primary mechanism by which nucleolar bivalents meet each other and, consequently, become associated either through common nucleolus formation or by heterochromatin coalescence.

Chromosomally derived sterile mice have a 'fertile' active XY chromatin conformation but no XY body.

We have previously shown that the sex chromosome bivalent of normal, fertile male mice possesses extensive regions of potentially active chromatin, even though, as has been shown by others, certain X-linked genes, and perhaps most of the X chromosome, become inactivated during pachytene. The male meiosis of a fertile (2;11) translocation carrier mouse, a chromosomally derived sterile (11; 19) translocation carrier and that of normal mice is compared. In situ nick translation shows a similar DNase I sensitivity pattern in the sex chromosomes of all examined mice. The X chromosome has four regions of potentially active chromatin conformation, two at the ends of the chromosome and two interstitial ones, coinciding with flexures which become prominent towards late pachytene. The Y chromosome is almost uniformly sensitive to DNase I. The similarity of chromatin conformation patterns in fertile and sterile mice is compatible with the hypothesis that unscheduled transcription of particular genes, possibly included in the active conformation regions, occurs in mice which become sterile. In the sterile (11;19) translocation carrier, a vast majority of all pachytenes are "associated": usually one unpaired segment of chromosome 19 is in end-to-end contact with the X chromosome. The tips of both unpaired segments of chromosome 19 have a thickened axis and display a peculiar chromatin appearance, similar to the modification of the centromeric tip of the X chromosome. Telomeric unpairedness of certain chromosome segments seems to be conducive to autosome-X chromosome association. We suggest that compartmentalization of the nucleus into an autosome mass and a fully developed, protruding, metabolically quiescent XY body, is a precondition for the normal progressing of meiosis. In the associated cells, the autosomal quadrivalent anchors the XY bivalent among the autosomes; as a consequence no XY body is formed. This interference with the course of compartmentalization leads to the abolishment of inactivation of part or all of the potentially active genes and results in meiotic arrest, and hence in sterility.

Relationship between nucleoli and sex chromosomes during meiosis of the male wood lemming Myopus schisticolor: a fine‐structure study

Electron microscopy of ultrathin serial sections has been used to study the origin and fate of a mass of fibrillar material (FM) during spermatogenesis in the wood lemming Myopus schisticolor. In the course of early pachytene, one of the two nucleoli completely disappears. The remaining nucleolus loses its granular portion and acquires a "round body" encased by the fibrillar moiety, and the restructuring is accompanied by the appearance of FM in the close vicinity of this nucleolus. During diakinesis, the FM increases in volume and density and selectively infiltrates the chromatin of the XY pair. The intermingling of sex chromosomes and FM is at its maximum in metaphase I, giving the XY chromatin a patchy appearance. The FM separates along with the chromatin during the ensuing anaphase I and is shed from the chromosomes during early telophase I. By the time the nuclear envelope is reconstituted, the FM is completely separated from the chromatin. It disintegrates in the spermatids. The FM could not be stained using the Ag-NOR technique. In the wood lemming, X and Y chromosomes show an end-to-end association without a detectable synaptonemal complex. The FM may contribute to the attachment of the two sex chromosomes to each other. Thus, the FM is considered to be a substitute for a chiasma, which normally guarantees proper segregation in anaphase I.