Wide-flange columns are commonly used for the construction of special moment frames and braced frames. For special moment frames, design engineers routinely use deep sections to meet the stringent code-specified story drift limits in order to achieve economy in recent years. Columns with shallow and stocky sections are common for braced frame construction. Observation made from two recent experimental studies involving both deep and shallow columns under axial compression and cyclic drifts showed a variety of buckling modes. A classification with three cyclic buckling modes is proposed in this paper; subsets of each buckling mode are also presented. A parameter measuring the relative rotational restraint that the web provides to each flange is derived. After calibrating this parameter with the test results, a practical procedure that can predict the governing cyclic buckling mode is proposed.